Ecobee vs Amazon Thermostat: Side-by-Side Comparison With Mysa

The Ecobee vs Amazon thermostat comparison is interesting because these brands make totally different devices. One is a premium, feature-loaded unit, and the other is a stripped-down budget pick. 

The right choice between the Amazon Smart Thermostat vs Ecobee Thermostat depends entirely on what you need from your thermostat and how much you're willing to spend to get it. We'll cover the pros and cons of each, compare them head-to-head, and explain why Mysa's smart thermostat might be the strongest option of the three. Learn more below!

Ecobee vs Amazon Thermostat vs Mysa Smart Thermostat

Pros and Cons of Ecobee Thermostats

Ecobee is the premium option in this Ecobee vs Amazon Thermostat comparison. The Smart Thermostat Premium ($260) combines a touchscreen, built-in Alexa and Siri, air quality monitoring, and radar-based occupancy detection. 

The brand’s mid-range Smart Thermostat Enhanced ($200) strips out the speaker and air quality sensor but keeps the core smart thermostat functionality if you want to save a bit of money. 

As one of the longest-standing brands in the home thermostat market, Ecobee is an excellent starting point when looking to upgrade your home climate control.

Pros

• Compatible with Alexa, Google Home, Apple HomeKit, SmartThings
• SmartSensor comes standard with the Premium model
• Built-in voice assistant doubles as a wall-mounted smart speaker
• No C-wire needed since the Power Extender Kit is included
• Well-designed app with responsive controls
• ENERGY STAR certified

Cons

• Expensive at up to $260 for the latest generation device
• Smart Security features (smoke detection, motion alerts) locked behind a $5-$10/month subscription
• Built-in Alexa mic is on by default and has to be manually disabled
• Occupancy-based scheduling can sometimes override your manual settings
• Only covers standard 24V HVAC thermostats (no baseboard, mini-split, or in-floor support)
• No Matter certification

Pros and Cons of Amazon's Smart Thermostat

The Amazon Smart Thermostat is a single-product offering - one model, one price point. It’s actually built by Honeywell under Amazon's brand, so you can rest assured you’re getting a dependable device. It lives inside the Alexa ecosystem and delivers basic smart thermostat functionality at the lowest possible cost. 

Pros

• One of the most affordable smart thermostats available at just $60-$80
• Alexa integration for seamless voice control, routines, and scheduling through the Alexa app
• Alexa Hunches suggests schedule adjustments based on your patterns
• ENERGY STAR certified
• No subscription fees
• Compact, seamless design

Cons

• Alexa only (no Apple HomeKit or Google Home)
• Basic LED display with no touchscreen
• No room sensors or occupancy detection
• C-wire required - no adapter included in the box
• Minimal energy reporting with no real-time tracking
• No air quality, humidity sensing, or advanced comfort features
• Only works with standard 24V HVAC

Amazon Thermostat vs Ecobee Thermostat: Which Is Better?

It’s actually pretty easy to choose between the Amazon Smart Thermostat vs Ecobee since they’re designed for totally different people. Ecobee is the premium option with a more sophisticated set of features, while Amazon’s smart thermostat punches well above its weight at a lower price.

Here's how the Ecobee vs Amazon thermostats compare across the categories that count.

Smart Home Ecosystem

This is the single biggest divide in the Ecobee vs Amazon Thermostat matchup. Amazon's thermostat works exclusively with Alexa. It simply won’t connect if you use Google Home or Apple HomeKit. This is a dealbreaker for anyone running a mixed smart home or planning to build one. 

For comparison, Ecobee supports everything from Alexa to Google, HomeKit, and SmartThings. It is not a Matter smart thermostat, though, which means it technically falls a little short compared to other options like Mysa.

Display, Sensors, and Controls

The Amazon thermostat keeps it minimal with a small LED readout with basic on-unit controls. No touchscreen, room sensors, or environmental awareness. 

On the other hand, the Ecobee Premium is equipped with a full-color touchscreen and a SmartSensor for multi-room temperature readings. Radar-based occupancy detection adjusts heating and cooling based on whether anyone's actually in the room. 

As you can imagine from the differences in cost alone, you just get more with Ecobee than you do Amazon.

Energy Monitoring

Both options in the Ecobee vs Amazon Thermostat comparison carry the ENERGY STAR label, but they help you save in very different ways. 

The Amazon thermostat does so through Alexa Hunches. These automated suggestions tweak your schedule over time, but you get almost zero visibility into actual consumption. Ecobee provides monthly energy reports and can adjust based on occupancy data so you’re not wasting money heating/cooling spaces when you don’t need to.

Neither offers the kind of real-time energy tracking with cost breakdowns that lets you see exactly where your money goes, though. That should be taken into account.

Installation

The Amazon Smart Thermostat vs Ecobee installation experience differs in one key way: the C-wire.

Ecobee includes a Power Extender Kit, so a missing C-wire is never a problem. The Amazon thermostat requires a C-wire and doesn't include an adapter, though. That means you might need to purchase one separately or pay for an electrician if your home's wiring doesn't have one. 

That hidden cost closes the price gap in older homes. Speaking of cost…

Price and Value

Amazon's thermostat runs $60-$80. The Ecobee Premium is roughly $260. That's a 3-4x gap! But don’t make the decision based on cost alone. The Amazon thermostat vs Ecobee decision depends on how much you actually need from your thermostat. 

Amazon definitely delivers if basic Alexa control and scheduling on a budget is all you're after. Ecobee earns its price if you want broad smart home support, room sensors, a real display, and premium features - though the $5-$10/month Smart Security subscription adds up over time.

Remember, though, you don’t have to choose between the Ecobee vs Amazon thermostat. You can also take some time to look at what sits between them.

Does Mysa Make Better Smart Thermostats Than Ecobee or Amazon?

We know all too well that the Amazon smart thermostat vs Ecobee comparison feels like choosing between too little and too much. The truth is, neither brand was built to cover the middle ground.

Mysa's low-voltage smart thermostat for central HVAC is $159. For roughly double the Amazon thermostat's price, you get real-time energy monitoring with cost tracking, Matter smart thermostat certification, full compatibility with HomeKit, Google Home, and Alexa, geofencing, vacation mode, and every feature unlocked with no subscription. It’s $100 less than the Ecobee Premium without the monthly upsells, too!

The Amazon thermostat and Ecobee only work with standard 24V HVAC, though. Mysa covers that, plus an electric baseboard heater thermostat, a mini split thermostat, and an electric in-floor heating thermostat - all managed from one app. Mysa is one of the few options with full smart home integration across every major platform for homes with high-voltage smart thermostat needs.

Landlords and second-home owners love our devices because remote access and geofencing let you manage energy without being on-site. Our guide to the best smart thermostat for rentals covers specific setups. 

You can also compare other options like our Sensibo vs Cielo comparison. But whether you’re looking for an Amazon or Ecobee alternative, look no further than Mysa. With more than 250,000 homes already connected, you’re joining good company!

Final Words on Our Amazon Smart Thermostat vs Ecobee Comparison

The Ecobee vs Amazon Thermostat decision comes down to two very different philosophies - do everything or spend as little as possible. Amazon gives you a functional, Alexa-only thermostat for under $80. Ecobee gives you a loaded, multi-platform experience for over $250. Both have their place.

But Mysa offers a third path if the Amazon thermostat vs Ecobee tradeoff doesn't sit right: real-time energy tracking, Matter certification, no subscriptions, and the only lineup that covers central HVAC, baseboard, mini-splits, and in-floor heating under one roof. 

Sometimes the best option isn't at either end of the shelf - it’s somewhere in the middle. Make the switch to ysa today and see what has homeowners raving about our devices!